If You Could Play Any Sport, Which One Should You Choose?

If You Could Play Any Sport, Which One Should You Choose?

Kyler Murray during college football playoffs in December 2018.
Photo: Mark Brown/Getty Images

For anyone who grew up in the 1990s, the idea that Kyler Murray, the Heisman Trophy winner and Oakland A’s first-round draft pick who announced Monday that he would declare himself eligible for the NFL draft, should have to choose one sport or another to dedicate his life to strikes one as fundamentally anti-joy. The ’90s were the heyday of two-sport stars, from Deion Sanders to Brian Jordan to Kenny Lofton to, of course, Bo Jackson, a man so athletically gifted that an entire Nike campaign revolved solely around his ability to dominate whatever sport he wanted to.

It was almost as if we wouldn’t accept Michael Jordan as the dominant athlete he was until we saw him trying on a baseball uniform.

There was something magical back then about someone like Bo, or Deion, or John Elway before them, or even Jim Thorpe, a player so purely blessed by the gods with otherworldly talent — talent being a primary reason we watch sports, after all — that he could lord his skill over all in whatever pursuit he chose. Surely, it was more viscerally thrilling than today’s era of specialization, where a 12-year-old can be plucked from his home, fed to some specific training facility in Florida, and emerge as a fully formed, perfectly honed specialist, his body sculpted and toned for the one purpose of whatever sport has been chosen for him. (At the expense, often, of any sort of socialization or exposure to anything else in the world.) As anyone who has spent any time around youth sports can tell you, the American sports world of today cannot accommodate such versatility: We demand that 7-year-olds pick their lane, let alone Heisman Trophy winners.

Which is why, from the beginning, the expectation has been that Murray would have to choose, and it is worth noting that just because Murray has put his name in the NFL draft does not mean he has currently chosen; he has roughly four weeks, during the crossover of the NFL draft combine and spring training for the A’s, to come to a final decision. And it is telling, in our wonkish, data-driven, brand-called-me world, that the decision is framed in entirely business terms. The one piece of information that no one has about Murray’s ultimate decision is which sport, you know, he likes more, and it’s not considered particularly relevant. As baseball writer Joe Sheehan put it in his weekly newsletter, “Murray will never be in a better position to turn his considerable athletic talent into money.” I understand that Murray has to make the best business decision for his life and career, but forgive me for lamenting a bit of lost romance in the zero-sum game this has become. (Of course, it’s also worth noting that sports were not so innocent in the ’90s either. Elway only threatened to play baseball because he wanted to force the Colts, who had drafted him, to trade him to the Broncos; Jackson agreed to play for the Royals because he refused to report to the woeful Tampa Buccaneers.)

Perhaps inevitably, Murray’s decision, whenever he makes it, will play like a referendum on the sports and professional leagues of baseball and football themselves. The thinking goes that baseball needs Murray to choose it because of the league’s issues with African-American participation and because Murray, perhaps immediately, would become one of the ten most recognizable faces in the sport (and that probably includes Tim Tebow); football needs Murray to choose it so it can show that, despite the alarming increase in CTE diagnoses and the league’s reputation for treating its players as a series of interchangeable body parts, it’s still irresistible for anyone who wants to be at the center of the American conversation. (The NFL can’t start losing players to old man baseball.) The leagues (obviously) will both be just fine, but considering how much each has been criticized over the years for how little it has to offer the individual — the NFL has had countless labor wars over its treatment of players, and MLB, considering the current frozen free-agent market, may be on the verge of one — having one of the most well-known athletes in the country choose their sport will be, at the very least, worthy of a little social-media celebration dance.

Which begs the question: If we accept that the world will no longer allow for multiple-sport stars, what sport should a burgeoning superstar choose? I’m not just talking about Murray, who has his own particular strengths and skills and suitabilities. Let’s create a mythical, hypothetical 18-year-old wunderkind, who is like Bo Jackson but better at everything (yikes, did you ever look at Bo’s K/BB ratio?), and theoretically able to dominate at whatever sport he (or she, one supposes) desires. Let’s call him Will Leitch, because even 43-year-old sportswriters can live out youthful athletic fantasies every once in a while, okay?

So: What team sport should young Will play, using the apparently universally accepted do-what’s-good-for-your-bottom-line metric? I add the “team” there because, long term, I don’t think golf, tennis, or NASCAR is the right choice for Will here. The best golfer in the world, Justin Thomas, earned $8.7 million in 2018, which is a hefty sum that would nonetheless make him the 148th best-paid NBA player, the 129th best-paid MLB player, and the 149th best-paid NFL player. Even allotting for however much Callaway might be paying you to use their clubs, that’s pretty low for the best player in the world. (For comparison, the 149th-best golfer made $569,391 last year.) Tennis pays a little more — Novak Djokovic made $15.9 million in 2018 for winning two Majors, and four tournaments total, which wouldn’t put him in baseball’s top 50 — but, again, requires being the absolute best to reach even that rarified air.

So, if 18-year-old Will wants to maximize his earning potential and make sure he has the highest possible quality of life, he seems to have four options: baseball, football, basketball, or soccer.

The baseball versus football question is a tough one, for Murray and for Will. On one hand, the NFL famously doesn’t have guaranteed contracts; even if you’ve signed for six years, if you blow out your knee tomorrow, the team can cut you and not pay you a dime. Baseball works differently, which means that Murray, for example, has already banked around 40 percent of a $4.6 million signing bonus for the A’s, and as long as he eventually does play baseball, he’ll get the whole thing. The problem, of course, as Sheehan points out, “that’s the last baseball money he’s going to see for a long, long time.” Murray will have to play in the minors for several years — at a salary below minimum wage, thanks to Congress — before he even makes the MLB minimum of $535,000. After that, he’ll have to go through arbitration every year, each time earning well below a “market” rate, until he’s finally on the open market in 2025 … and that’s if everything goes perfect and he stays healthy and develops as expected. (And we’ve seen in the last two winters how unperfect MLB free agency is, even when healthy and monstrously well-developed talent is available.) The NFL does give its first-round draftees more money than baseball does; to quote Sheehan again, “Murray can make more money just by being drafted by an NFL team than he can by playing baseball for the next seven or eight years.” This is widely considered the reason Murray is keeping his options open: He wants the A’s to give him more money up-front (reportedly $15 million) to make it worth his while to stay. Of course, he might also get a brain injury before those seven or eight years are over, and baseball players’ careers last far longer than only the greatest NFL careers. It’s basic risk-reward: Is Murray willing to sacrifice long-term security for more guaranteed short-term gain? (Also: How much does he like being yelled at on television? Stephen A. Smith will lambaste him much less if he plays baseball. Worth considering.)

Young Will Leitch, though, has two other options. If he’s, say, chosen first overall in the NBA draft, like the Phoenix Suns’ Deandre Ayton last April, he’s looking at a guaranteed $18,107,160 over his first two seasons, with the possibility of $41,242,888 over the four years of his rookie contract. Even if he’s the final pick of the first round, like Atlanta’s Omari Spellman, he’s booked for $3,593,640 over the first two years, which isn’t far from what Murray signed with Oakland for. And at the top end, NBA players are extremely well-compensated: Stephen Curry has made $37.5 million a year each of the last two years. But the NBA still has a math problem: The fewest number of roster spots, 15 per team, than any other sport, along with a development league that pays about $35,000 a year, which is only a little bit more than MLB’s minor leaguers make. European leagues are there as a backup — some Euro and Russian teams pay six or even low-seven figures — but those have a shelf life too; they don’t have many more roster spots there. And no league has more of an issue with salary disparity between superstars and rank and file than the NBA does; under union chief Michele Roberts, this is, in large part, official policy.

But I think I know what 18-year-old Will Leitch should do: If he has soccer mastered, he should play that. Last month, the rights to Christian Pulisic — last seen desperately trying (and failing) to will older, lesser American soccer players to the World Cup — were bought by English Premier League team Chelsea from German Bundesliga team Borussia Dortmund for a $77 million transfer fee, the most ever paid for an American player and a sign that Chelsea considers him a future star. And stars, in soccer, make a shocking amount of money thanks to a sport that, because there are so many international leagues with so much competition, has no real salary cap. Last year Lionel Messi made more than $100 million in salary, and that’s not even counting endorsements. Pulisic, or young Leitch, will have the freedom to play in any soccer league in the world, and he will be able to make tens of millions of dollars when he’s a teenager and as he matures and improves as a player. There is no artificial league cap (except in the MLS), no one-league-or-nothing constraint, and, oh yes, he plays the most popular sport in the world, and he can play it anywhere. And he can do it well into his 30s, even his 40s. And he’s unlikely to suffer any serious head injuries, or get screamed about on First Take. He’ll have the best of every possible world. That’s where American sports leagues are at this particular point in history. All things being equal: Your kid should just play soccer.

If You Could Play Any Sport, Which One Should You Choose?

Promoted links by Taboola

Putin gets another win

BREAKING: Senate GOP defeats Dem measure to enforce sanctions against companies controlled by Russian oligarch OLEG DERIPASKA.

Dems needed 60 votes, only got 57, even after GOP defections.

Sanctions now all but certain to be lifted this week pursuant to TRUMP administration deal.


Democrats are getting serious about raising wages for workers across the country

Democrats introduced a bill Wednesday to gradually raise the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour, a long-shot plan that comes as the party tries to bill itself as a champion of the working class.

The proposal to hike the U.S. wage floor from the current $7.25 will likely fail in the GOP-held Senate even if it gets through the Democratic-controlled House. However, the new House Democratic majority sees the measure as a message that it wants to lift low-wage workers and boost the economy — and an effort to focus on its policy priorities amid the longest government shutdown ever.

The Raise the Wage Act, backed by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and several declared or prospective 2020 Democratic presidential candidates, would hike the minimum wage to $15 per hour by 2024 through annual increases. It would also end provisions that in some cases allow employers to pay workers under age 20 and employees with disabilities less than the wage floor.

Theresa May finally wins a vote

BREAKING: Theresa May’s government survives Labour’s no confidence vote by 325 votes to 306, majority 19. Her premiership lives to fight another day.


The Senate tried, and failed, to stop the administration from removing sanctions on a Russian oligarch

BREAKING: Senate GOP defeats Dem measure to enforce sanctions against companies controlled by Russian oligarch OLEG DERIPASKA.

Dems needed 60 votes, only got 57, even after GOP defections.

Sanctions now all but certain to be lifted this week pursuant to TRUMP administration deal.


life in pixels

Facebook Doesn’t Need to Fool You

By Max Read

Is the #10YearChallenge meme a conspiracy to steal your data?

Trump is losing the shutdown

As a consequence of the shutdown of the federal government, do you feel more negative or more positive toward President Trump? (via PBS/Marist poll)

62% more negative

29% more positive

6% neither


Don’t call it a comeback

Sears Holdings Corp Chairman Eddie Lampert prevailed in a bankruptcy auction for the U.S. department store chain with an improved takeover bid of roughly $5.2 billion, allowing the 126-year-old retailer to keep its doors open, people familiar with the matter said Wednesday.

Lampert’s bid, boosted from an earlier $5 billion offer, prevailed after weeks of back-and-forth deliberations that culminated in a days-long bankruptcy auction held behind closed doors. The billionaire’s proposal, made through his hedge fund ESL Investments Inc, will save up to 45,000 jobs and keep 425 stores open across the United States.

government shutdown

government shutdown

If TSA Workers Go on Strike, Trump Might Relish the Chance to Play Reagan

By Ed Kilgore

It’s unclear if Trump could follow Reagan’s strategy for defeating striking air traffic controllers. Unpaid TSA workers might be tempted to try him.


YouTube Bans Dangerous Pranks Like the ‘Bird Box Challenge’

By Brian Feldman

YouTubers are no longer allowed to risk or make anyone fear for their lives.

The CEO of WeWork, recently valued at $47 billion, has a questionable side hustle

Mr. Neumann has made millions of dollars by leasing multiple properties in which he has an ownership stake back to WeWork, one of the country’s most valuable startups. Multiple investors of the privately held company said the arrangement concerned them as a potential conflict of interest in which the CEO could benefit on rents or other terms with the company.

select all

Instagram Influencer Un-Cancels Infamous Creativity Tour

By Madison Malone Kircher

Caroline Calloway is back, baby.

Watch out for literal fake news in D.C. today

Did T-Mobile try to bribe Trump?

Last April, telecom giant T-Mobile announced a megadeal: a $26 billion merger with rival Sprint, which would more than double T-Mobile’s value and give it a huge new chunk of the cellphone market.

But for T-Mobile, one hurdle remained: Its deal needed approval from the Trump administration.

The next day, in Washington, staffers at the Trump International Hotel were handed a list of incoming “VIP Arrivals.” That day’s list included nine of T-Mobile’s top executives — including its chief operating officer, chief technology officer, chief strategy officer, chief financial officer and its outspoken celebrity chief executive, John Legere.

They were scheduled to stay between one and three days. But it was not their last visit.

alexandria ocasio-cortez

alexandria ocasio-cortez

Who Is Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Like in American History? Historians Weigh In

By Benjamin Hart

Shirley Chisholm? Joshua Reed Giddings? FDR?

government shutdown

government shutdown

The Longer the Shutdown Lasts, the More It Hurts the Economy

By Adam K. Raymond

Even the White House’s own economic adviser is warning about the damage inflicted by the never-ending shutdown.

As long as Pence doesn’t call ISIS the “JV team,” nobody in conservative media will care

On day ISIS is claiming responsibility for the deadly attack in Syria, Vice President Pence said in speech at State Department a few minutes ago “The caliphate has crumbled and ISIS has been defeated.”


In a way, it’s surprising that Mike Tyson hasn’t played more of a role in the Trump presidency

When a frustrated adviser once tried to convince President Trump to consider a strategic plan, the president launched into a story about his friend Mike Tyson, the former world heavyweight boxing champion.

What he’s saying: “Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the mouth,” Trump said, echoing a famous Tyson quote.

I had asked the adviser whether Trump ever expressed frustration that his West Wing lacked enough of a plan for the crises ahead.

“He gets frustrated when there is a plan,” the adviser said.

“He’s not a guy who likes a plan. … There’s an animosity towards planning, and there’s a desire to pick fights that have nothing to do with us.”


Most Americans Don’t Know How Much Facebook Knows About Them

By Jake Swearingen

Per a new survey, odds are you haven’t seen the detailed psychographic profile Facebook has on you — and you’d be uncomfortable once you did.

Trump continues not to know what Democrats want or need

I think yesterday’s debacle, of swing district House Dems turning down an invitation to the White House, has been underplayed. This WH is just uniquely bad at getting inside the heads of the opposition party. Doesn’t understand that it has its own base, incentives.


The better move would be to delay the State of the Union until never

Citing furloughs at DHS and Secret Service, Pelosi asks Trump to delay this month’s State of the Union until AFTER the government is reopened, per

@FoxReports @arogDC


Gillibrand is IN

A bloody reminder that ISIS is by no means extinguished in Syria

 The Islamic State claimed responsibility Wednesday for a suicide blast in Syria’s U.S.-patrolled city of Manbij, marking the first such attack since President Trump said American forces would be withdrawing from the country because the militant group had largely been defeated.

A statement published by the militants’ unofficial news agency, Amaq, said the attacker used an explosive vest to target coalition forces. The agency presented no further evidence for the claim.

Photographs from the area appeared to show bodies and blood trails strewn across the ground. It was not immediately clear whether U.S. personnel were in the area at the time. 

The Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said at least 19 people were wounded or killed in the blast. A Kurdish news agency said at least 10 people were injured, locating the attack at the site of a popular restaurant. 

Chris Christie’s new tell-all sounds fun

Christie: Trump has a “revolving door of deeply flawed individuals — amateurs, grifters, weaklings, convicted and unconvicted felons — who were hustled into jobs they were never suited for, sometimes seemingly without so much as a background check via Google or Wikipedia.”



the national interest

the national interest

If Only Obama Had Done the Things Obama Actually Did

By Jonathan Chait

Some on the left have repeated their complaints about Obama’s supposed failures so many times, they’ve forgotten everything he actually accomplished.


A plum gig for AOC

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has officially gotten a slot on House Financial Services: A New York Democrat who will rail against Wall Street on key panel


Trump now literally has blood on his hands

The back of Trump’s right hand was covered with an adhesive bandage during a Thursday trip to McAllen, Texas, with blood visibly seeping through the dressing. His hand was similarly bandaged again on Monday as he departed for a trip to New Orleans.

Armchair medics studying photos that circulated online this week leapt to dramatic conclusions. But the White House said on Tuesday that Trump sustained the injury while playing with his 12-year-old son. “The President was having fun and joking around with his son Barron and scratched his hand,” White House press secretary Sarah Sanders told POLITICO.

Florida city commissioner launches racist petition to remove Representative Rashida Tlaib, is now facing calls for her own resignation

A Florida city commissioner is under fire after calling Rep. Rashida Tlaib, who made history as one of the first Muslim members of Congress, a “danger” who might “blow up” the U.S. Capitol. 

The comments were made by Annabelle Lima-Taub, a city commissioner in the south Florida city of Hallandale Beach, in the aftermath of Tlaib saying she wanted to “impeach that motherf—-,” a reference to President Donald Trump.

Lima-Taub signed an online petition that aimed to remove Tlaib from office and wrote a message about Tlaib on her personal Facebook page, according to the South Florida Sun-Sentinel

“Proudly signed,” Lima-Taub wrote, according to a screen grab of the post. “A Hamas-loving anti-Semite has NO place in government! She is a danger and [I] would not put it past her to become a martyr and blow up Capitol Hill.”

Is he a Russian agent? Sure, but I wouldn’t say he’s doing his job effectively

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov dismissed claims that President Donald Trump has been working on the Kremlin’s behalf as he attacked Congress and the American media for undermining the U.S. leader.

“It’s hard for me to comment on what is happening in the U.S. surrounding accusations that President Trump is effectively a Russian agent,” Lavrov said at his annual press conference in Moscow on Wednesday.

He accused American media of “lowering their journalistic standards” in coverage of the issue and denounced U.S. lawmakers for challenging Trump’s right to conduct foreign policy. “This right is under attack from Congress and this doesn’t make these attacks constitutional or less illegal.”

The only part of Manafort’s entire day that did not involve colluding with Russia was when he ate a sandwich